So what you are saying is that you can either 1. Have a game that is fun to play or 2. Have a game where you get 0 kills. Hmmm... I wonder what 99.9% of players will choose. I love the way Squad plays, I am an old Project Reality player, where you counted in your head 3 seconds after sprinting so your aim would be 100% accurate, as fun as Project Reality was, it did not require much skill to play, proper positioning, using terrain to your advantage and communication was the key to high K/D.
Furthermore, I would like to point out that when you are holding a rifle, you know what direction it will sway because you can feel it on your body, you feel it with your fingers, hands and shoulder, so you can predict where its gonna move, we dont get that feeling in Video games.
You talk about skill, Im not a ''pro'' by any means but I have played with different people, and you can tell who is brain dead and who isnt. I on average get +/- 20 kills infantry each game with less than 5 deaths. Its not skill, its my positioning, theres no aiming skill involved in squad. This is not CSGO, where the map is linear and enemy can only come from one side. I had instances where I wiped out a squads with 1 grenade, that doesnt require aiming skill, should we make grenades more realistic too?
Please chill out with these threads. You want and extremely realistic game? Get yourself a VR headset and go play Onward, or better yet, join the Army.